Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  

Subscribe versus account- best practices?

Recommended Posts


Throwing this out here since I'm having *splendid* luck with assistance via PL staff today (Yay Rob!).


I've got a site... don't we all?


Running WP/Pagelines with Woocommerce- blog and store. All 3 pieces of this puzzle have their own way of allowing access/maintaining subscriber/customer/user databases. And it seems EXTREMELY dumb + confusing + redundant (in the bad way) to have 3 different ways for someone to become part of your list, all with different functions.


Has anyone had this issue before? How did you solve it? Do you choose one and dump the others? Don't want that because I want people to have the benefit of all 3 (commenting, subscriptions, store account). Could they be smushed together in some seamless and elegant way? Am I in over my head? (WAIT- do NOT answer that last one!)


Okay geniuses, I await the brilliance of the PL hive mind.


Bree :)

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
James B

Hi Bree


Are you intending for customers to sign up to an account prior to purchasing?


Rob would really be the best person to advise on this as he runs a large site with a subscription and ecommerce facility. I'm not sure how he manages though. I've copied him in this thread and he'll be in tomorrow so he'll be able to let you know his setup or the options he's tried previously.

Kindly search the forum and read the documentation before posting. It will help you resolve many issues.

For CSS help be sure to check out W3Schools first and be sure to download FireBug for FireFox for troubleshooting.

James B

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks James!


Ideal functionality:

  • Users will not need to sign up prior to purchasing but an account will be created via the purchasing process.
  • Users must sign up to comment
  • Users must sign up to subscribe to the blog



Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites



James is partially correct... I do have a large site, but my ecommerce is all done via Amazon.


The ecommerce plugin has to be able to manage your client account registration, but to be honest, consumers are very wary of those sites which require any registration and there's no security certificate (you'd see a locked padlock in the browser).  They don't like putting credit card info, addresses, names or email addresses into forms that are not secured.


To force a person to sign up before commenting, you need to go to Dashboard > Settings > Discussion and review the options there. You'll find one that says something like "User must be registered before commenting" or something like that. 


Use a 3rd party commenting system like Disqus if you'd like. That helps reduce spam.  Also make sure you have an Akismet account setup (usually free if you do it right) and activate it.  That helps kill most spam.


Now subscribing to the blog is not as difficult as it would seem.  I use a great membership plugin called s2Member that compels registration before accessing certain pages.  It's free and does a great job.


Shop around for the best pricing on security certificates (SSL) for your site.  This is going to be an annual cost, which shouldn't cost more than $79 for your site.  You'd buy those from companies like Verisign or your registrar.

Former PageLines Moderator, Food Expert and Raconteur

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi Rob- good morning (and thanks for the great info)!


I currently have all 3 options set up (subscription through Feedburner, have not chosen a payment gateway yet), but it feels so darn cluttered. For example, if someone has already subscribed they still need to create a user account to comment. Or if they have already created their store account they cannot automatically comment. Have you implemented anything to streamline/sync this options?



Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites



Feedburner is an RSS subscription process.  Totally different from what you described.


I'd use s2Member. 


Include comments only on the posts that are within the membership area. That way, they don't have to subscribe to comment separately from subscribing to view the protected posts (or content). You streamline it into one process for the viewer and yourself. As for the store aspects, protecting that so that someone has to be registered to purchase is a function of your ecommerce solution.


Payment gateways are tricky because you have to evaluate so many variables.  Its not something I deal with, so you'll be best to get advice on this from a hosting company or from solid due diligence into the various programs available.

Former PageLines Moderator, Food Expert and Raconteur

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Thank you buckets and buckets, Rob!

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

No problems.

Former PageLines Moderator, Food Expert and Raconteur

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • mtaus
      By mtaus+
      I'm using Woocommerce in a Pagelines framework. When I build out a product, I'm able to add images in the admin panel and the
      Product Image will display on Shop page, but neither the Product Image nor the Product Gallery will display on the product's dedicated page.
      Shop: https://bendbotanics.com/shop/
      Product Example: https://bendbotanics.com/product/500mg-full-spectrum-hemp-oil-fsho/
      Any help would be greatly appreciated!
    • cdracos
      By cdracos+
      Hello everyone,
      I face a common problem as I can see on relevant topics with quickshop plugin. 
      On Product Single page of woocommerce, i use quickshop as layout. The primary photo of my product doesn't appear on the thumb slider, but the first image is the default placeholder. 
      Need some help not with custom script in the product description for each product. 
      Have a look on my website: http://lillyandsid.gr/shop/camp-things-top/
    • ideascurator
      By ideascurator+
      Hello Pagelines,   I no longer use pagelines services. I have deactivated the automatic annual payment. But it already charged to my credit card. Since I cancelled my contract before the end, Can I request to refund?
    • Anthony King
      By Anthony King+
      I am wanting to know what the status of the Pagelines Platform.
      I have noticed that there has been absolutely no updates on Platform 5 for over 8 months.
      Please tell me you haven't gone off on another tangent and going to build the next great solution
      and then leave all of us to have to completely rebuild our sites like we did for
      Pagelines, then DMS, then Pagelines Platform.
      I like what you build, but what you need to do is build one product and then make it better, rather than 
      abandoning it and building something else.
      You haven't done anything for so long that even WordPress is providing a warning.
      "Warning: This plugin has not been tested with your current version of WordPress."
      So what is the Status. I mean if I am going to pay a monthly fee for a product, I don't want to pay for one
      that is no longer being supported. You have a great product, I'm not bashing it, I'm just wondering what 
      your next move is because I have business decisions to make for myself, and whether of not this is something
      I should stick with.

      Please be kind enough to respond.

      Thank You,
    • stebac
      By stebac+

      Since i recently updated to WordPress 4.9.4 there have been some unusual behaviours with Platform 5 (version 5.1.8).

      I am unable to edit the colour pickers for the backgrounds (the boxes do not show up anymore) and when i activate a plugin from the extend menu it does not show up in my page editor tools.
      Is this a problem for everyone else?
      Thank you in advance for your time.